What Hollywood Can Learn from West Point — Henry Ossian Flipper

By Jay Holmes

Henry Ossian Flipper of the West Point Class of 1877 was the first African-American graduate from the US military academy. Born a slave in Georgia in 1856, Henry attended Atlanta University after the Civil War. During his first year, he received an appointment to West Point from US Congressman James C Freeman.

Lieutenant Henry Ossian Flipper

Flipper was not the first African-American to attend West Point, but he was the first to graduate. Life at West Point has never been easy for any cadet, but black cadets suffered the extra stress of racial hatred from some of the senior white cadets. Yet Flipper survived the rough treatment and graduated.

After receiving a commission as a second lieutenant in the US Army, Flipper was assigned to the US 10th Cavalry Regiment in the Oklahoma Indian Territory, a regiment of black soldiers traditionally led by white officers. The 10th Cavalry had moved to Texas before Flipper’s arrival. However, Flipper spent three months in Oklahoma supervising engineering projects, including road building and telegraph line construction, before he received orders in October to travel to Texas to join his regiment.

Lieutenant Flipper reported to Captain Nicholas Nolan, and Nolan assigned him to command A Troop of the 10th Cavalry. Nolan apparently treated Flipper as he would any new lieutenant, and this was resented by some of the white officers at the fort. Flipper would at times eat at captain Nolan’s dinner table with Nolan’s family. When some of the officers complained, Nolan explained that Flipper was an officer and a gentleman like any other officer at the post.

Captain Nicholas M. Nolan

When the 10th Cavalry was sent to Fort Elliot in Texas, Captain Nolan became the fort commander. He appointed Flipper as his adjutant. Flipper undoubtedly earned the jealousy of those officers with racist tendencies, and, according to Flipper’s writings, not all of his critics hid their anger.

When Captain Nolan’s sister-in-law, Mollie Dwyer, visited Fort Elliot, she and Flipper became friends and would go riding together. Although Captain Nolan and his wife were happy that Mollie was in the company of a trustworthy officer, not everyone at the fort was willing to tolerate a white woman being escorted by a black officer. A smear campaign was conducted against Flipper, but apparently officers further up the chain of command accepted Captain Nolan’s opinion of Flipper, and the allegations of impropriety were ignored.

In late 1879, Fort Elliot became involved in a murky plot of sorts. One night, a federal marshal, Marshal Norton, arrived at the fort and turned over a local judge and some of his supporters for imprisonment. Captain Nolan was required by law to act as jailer for any prisoners turned over by US marshals, but he was suspicious of Norton and his cohorts. The telegraph line at the fort went dead, confirming his suspicions.

Nolan had Flipper and two troopers leave the fort in the middle of the night with the prisoners and escort them to another fort. Marshal Norton and his posse became aware of the midnight prisoner shuffle. They tracked down Flipper’s party and arrested them. One of Flipper’s troopers escaped pursuit and managed to warn Captain Nolan. Captain Nolan lead out a patrol, and they were able to catch up with the marshal.

Now pay attention. This gets tricky. When the captives, their escort, the captors of the escorts of the captives, and the captors of the captors of the escort of the captives ended up in front of a federal judge, Marshal Norton charged Nolan and Flipper with interfering with justice. The federal judge quickly declared them guilty and fined them each $1,000. As soon as Marshal Norton disappeared into the sunset, though, the judge suspended his own ruling and sent the soldiers happily on their way.

10th Cavalry

In 1879, Flipper was assigned to G Troop of the 10th Cavalry. During the 10th Cavalry’s participation in the ongoing Apache Wars, he served with distinction.

In late 1880, Flipper was assigned to Fort Davis and appointed as the fort’s quartermaster officer. In March of 1881, Colonel William Shafter took command of Fort Davis and relieved Lieutenant Flipper of his responsibility as quartermaster officer without any explanation. Shafter was apparently outspoken about his dislike of having black officers in the Army.

When money went unaccounted for in the commissary records, Shafter blamed Flipper. Flipper was court marshaled for embezzlement and “conduct unbecoming an officer.” Flipper was found innocent of the embezzlement charges, but guilty of the catch-all charge of conduct unbecoming an officer. Flipper was dismissed from the Army. From this distance, it appears that he was dismissed unfairly, and I have been unable to locate any evidence of any serious wrongdoing to support his dismissal.

After leaving the Army, Flipper pursued a successful engineering career in Texas, Mexico, and Venezuela. Flipper volunteered for service in the Spanish-American war of 1892, but his petition for reinstatement never received review.

In 1921, Albert Fall, the Secretary of Interior, appointed Flipper as his assistant.

Henry Ossian Flipper passed away in Atlanta Georgia in 1940.

In 1976, Flipper’s descendants petitioned the Army to review his case. The Army no longer had authority to overturn the century-old court-martial conviction, but the Army found that the conviction had been unjust, and they were able to issue a posthumous honorable discharge.

In 1997, a law firm applied for a full pardon for Flipper. Applications for executive pardons for courts-martial are almost always dismissed as a matter of policy. Fortunately, President Clinton took time from his hectic schedule to actually review the application, and he issued a full pardon of Henry Flipper in 1999. The pardon came 59 years too late for Flipper to enjoy the moment of vindication, but at least the record has been set straight for his family.

Henry Flipper’s history is important because it shows that as early as 1873, when Flipper entered West Point, some of the US Army’s leadership recognized the simple truth of human equality long before African-Americans were able to vote in many districts throughout the nation. When we juxtapose Flipper’s 1877 graduation from West Point with Rosa Park’s 1955 refusal to surrender her bus seat to a white rider, it forms something of a kaleidoscopic image of the irregular and somewhat jagged process of social change in America.

Often, the US Army is viewed by civilians as being ruled by medieval-minded WASPs who are doing their best to protect their Army from the dangers of progressive thinking. But in the case of Henry Flipper, it appears that the West Point establishment was more progressive than many segments of society were in 1877. It was an imperfect Army, and in the end Flipper did, indeed, fall victim to racism, but Flipper got further in the US Army than he could have in most national institutions in 1877.

The United States Naval Academy admitted African-American cadets as early as 1872. However, the academy staff treated them so badly that, to its everlasting shame, the US Naval Academy did not graduate it’s first African-American until 1949.

The United States Coast Guard considers itself to be the most forward looking and “liberal thinking” branch of the US services. Yet it was not until 1966 that the Coast Guard Academy in New London graduated it’s first African-American, Native American and Hispanic-American. The Service Academies graduated their first female cadets in 1980.

The wealthy elites who run Major League Baseball didn’t admit an African-American to their rosters until 1947, when Jackie Robinson joined the Brooklyn Dodgers. It’s an odd overlay of facts that, while African-Americans were trusted to lead US Army troops into war in 1877, and they were considered competent to perform the first open heart surgery in 1893, they could not be trusted with something as trivial as baseball until 1947, or sit on a bus in peace in Alabama in 1955.

Dr. Daniel Hale Williams–performed first open heart surgery

When Barack Obama became the first African-American to be elected President in 2008, Hollywood and TV media outlets were quick to point out that they had been “ahead of the curve” because they had portrayed African-American presidents on the screen. My, oh, my! How generous those Hollywood folks are. Actor and self-appointed social justice guardian George Clooney has explained to America that Hollywood leads the nation in progressive thinking and creates progressive trends. Georgie apparently fails to recognize that, while the US has an African-American president, and the US military had an African-American Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff appointed by President Bush in 1989, no major Hollywood studio has had a black CEO. The supposedly socially and politically liberal Screen Actors Guild also has yet to have an African-American president.

I wonder when the Hollywood Guardians of Progressive Thinking and their cousins in TV World will catch up to the 1877 West Point staff or the modern American voters. It will be a great day for America if it ever happens.


22 comments on “What Hollywood Can Learn from West Point — Henry Ossian Flipper

  1. Xandra James says:

    Very interesting! Thanks for sharing the history, Piper. Here’s to our progressive nations actually becoming progressive in the very near future! 😉

  2. Interesting bits of history. Thanks for digging this out, Piper.

  3. Gene Lempp says:

    Very well written post Piper. It has always saddened me how in the country that prides itself on freedom we find that the pride tends to be rhetorical and the reality little different than other places. This is not just a race based ideal either, but also a gender and socio-economic one. Thanks for sharing this wonderful tribute to the efforts and life of Mr. Flipper.

    • Piper Bayard says:

      Thanks Gene, but this one is all Holmes. I would respectfully disagree about the gender freedom. I am aware every day that I do not live in a country where I was castrated as a girl, I’m not forced to hide in a portable cloth cage, and I am not legally the property of the male members of my family. My parents do not choose my spouse, nor can they trade me off to pay their debts. Every day, i know that I am among the minority of women on this planet for whom choice and freedom are a reality, and I am profoundly grateful to every Susan B. Anthony, Dr. Elizabeth Blackwell, Arabella Mansfield, Esq., and General Ann E. Dunwoody who made this possible for the women of America. This country, while imperfect in enacting its ideals, really IS free for women. Thanks for stopping by and commenting. 🙂

  4. Amazing post! Great bit of history for me to read. So great, I think I’m going to share on FaceBook so that my parents will check it out. Good for Clinton (I never thought I’d say that). 🙂

  5. K.B. Owen says:

    Holmes writes another winner! I only knew sketchy details about Flipper. Amazing man. It takes a lot of courage and self-respect to handle the day-to-day bigotry, hostility and harrassment he obviously endured. I’m glad Clinton took the time to right that particular wrong. Our former president sure had his problems, but he’s still my favorite commander-in-chief of the last 50 yrs. (Ok, y’all, don’t get your knickers in a twist, that’s just my opinion).

    • J H says:

      Thank you KB. Bill was never my favorite but I think he got it right on Flipper. If you think about the relentless demands for a president’s time it’s almost a miracle that the request made it to his desk because his family members were probably not big donors.

  6. just think…. an entire article and no flippant references to the late 60’s TV show “Flipper” …as a passionate devotee of the show i couldn’t help slipping it in. been reading a bit o history myself this week. 1861 by Adam Goodheart which is about the state of the country during that turbulent year … timely that i get this history lesson today regarding this remarkable person. thanks holmes, stop by me blog for a spot o tea anytime …. I Tweet at @Samuel_Clemons

  7. Texanne says:

    Excellent post, Holmes. Thought-provoking. Hollywood is, of course, self-delusional, but that helps them to be creative, I suppose. Of course it had to be Clooney with the blatant falsehoods.

    I’m glad to hear about (I’ve forgotten what rank he rose to) Flipper. I did not know this. The military is a good place to start a career because advancement is awarded on the basis of tests, experience, performance reviews, and so forth. Nobody gets points for belonging to the same fraternity as The Old Man!

    You always give us something to think about, to be grateful for. 🙂

  8. educlaytion says:

    Great stuff Holmes. Always up for a swipe at Hollywood, but you’ve laid out such a wonderful story here. When I teach the Reconstruction era I always see students surprised to learn that multiple black men won seats in the national congress as well as scores more who took seats in state houses. The end of Flipper’s career is unfortunate, but at least history has been corrected. Well told tale.

  9. Dave says:

    We know about Flipper, but there had to be at least a few more like him that we’ll never know about. Hats off to all who served faithfully whose stories will never be told.

  10. amblerangel says:

    I really enjoyed that Holmes. Interesting and though provoking.

  11. Justice had been served…half a century too late. At least it’s been served.

Talk to us. We talk back.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s