Bayard, Holmes, Movie, No Popcorn: The Mechanic

By Piper Bayard & Jay Holmes

By popular request, Holmes and I went to see The Mechanic, a film about a hit man who kills his friend, and then takes in his friend’s son as his protégé. Jason Statham stars as Arthur Bishop, the hit man, and Ben Foster plays Steve McKenna, the pup he takes in. So here’s what an author/bellydancer and a man with experience in intelligence and covert operations have to say about this film. . . .

Overall, we think The Mechanic will rightfully appeal to people who like lots of action and explosions in their movies. There are several fun scenes that we won’t comment on because we don’t want to ruin the movie for you. However, Holmes and I agree the whole premise has a few drawbacks.

The first thing we spotted is that you don’t wait at the bottom of a pool to kill a guy, especially when you only have a small bottle of compressed air to breathe off of. What if that guy decides to shower or cozy up to one of his molls before he swims? You suffocate. And with four guys wielding machine guns outside the pool? No. You slip in when no one’s there, put a toxin in his swim goggles, and get gone, because the best place to be when your enemy dies is in another country.

Ben Foster as Steve McKenna

We also agree that no professional in any business knowingly pairs up with a mentally unstable, reckless individual. Even if Arthur had a momentary lapse of judgment out of compassion for his friend’s son, the first time the protégé deliberately disobeyed instructions, he’d be out the door wearing cement shoes. Professionals involved in any aspect of covert operations, legal or illegal, avoid associating with people who are obviously self-destructive because they just don’t recruit people who are going to burn down their world.

Now to our individual comments. I’m leaving this mostly to Holmes because of his expertise in covert operations.


As an author, I appreciated the smooth shifts in the antagonist focus. The Mechanic sorts through the bad guys and the good guys by bringing you along with the one consistent good guy. It’s an effective and artful way to traverse the twists of intrigue without dropping you into a high-speed blender.

And speaking of blenders, I liked that scene. You’ll know what I mean when you see it. Holmes liked it, as well, and thought it was one of the more plausible scenes in the film.

The Fantasy:  Handsome Arthur Bishop Always Wins

I don’t have any comments as a dancer, but as a woman, I can say that Arthur Bishop is a most appealing anti-hero. Very powerful and sexy with his own brand of integrity. Reality check to the ladies, though. Having a hit man for your love interest would have to seriously suck, no matter how handsome or smooth or classy he is, and most of them aren’t.  I mean, this is a guy who values cash above human life. Not only that, he’s gone all the time, he can’t say where or how long, and don’t even think about calling him. He’s the one going places and doing wild things. You’re the one working as a waitress in a sleazy bar, just hoping he’ll call.


This movie is not for everyone. It’s an action flick, and there’s more action than flick here. The writers, producers, and directors seemed to follow the tried and true approach of adding more explosions, gunshots, and noise whenever the writing became difficult.

I would say that the acting is better than the script. The conversations appear to be some writer’s first impression of what conversations in the real world might actually be like. Given the vast number of unemployed writers who have life experience and social contacts, I find the lack of polish and effort regrettable. With the bare minimum of dialogue taping together the action scenes, this was the script version of Queasy Cam.

Also, in movies, as in real life, chase scenes and shootouts are much more dramatic after a calm interval. Part of what makes action interesting in an action movie is that contrast. The Mechanic would be better by a whole notch if they left out 10 minutes of violence and replaced it with 10 more minutes of character development, setting, and dialogue.

I thought the sex was just enough that I would not bring any of my nieces to this movie. The visual and verbal allusions to sadomasochistic sex do fit the hit man’s character, but, in my view, they create a smaller audience for this movie. If you’re a dad, and you find yourself willing to share these scenes with your daughter, consider giving your daughter up for adoption while there’s still time for her to develop sanity. For that matter, I wouldn’t bring any guy or gal under the age of fifteen to this movie.

Now, if you’re curious about the plausibility of this movie, here’s my take. Let’s not bother with the procedural errors because you weren’t hoping that this movie would be an assassination manual, and if you were, I wouldn’t want to help you, anyway. . . . So the plausibility of this highly glamorous, 5-star living Murder Incorporated racket is nill. Why would you pay $50 million to kill somebody when you could pay 20 sleazebags $10k each and see who gets him first?

The idea of some big organization with several teams of assassins all working together in a collegial environment, completing hits at a breakneck pace (no pun intended)—it just doesn’t happen. With that many people involved, the risk of them turning state’s evidence would be beyond control, not to mention the supply and demand issue. These are killers who don’t share a goal or a value. Their only value is money, and there’s no way to hold a group of people together without some other common value. Organized crime struggles with this every day. If you want to know the reality, read the news about Mexican drug cartels. They are what happens when the only common ideology is wealth.

Our Rating:

With a little more character, setting and script development The Mechanic could have been a .357, but, as it is, we have to rate it a .38 special. (Click here for rating system.) There were enough creative action scenes (action as in murder) to make the movie worth seeing for action movie enthusiasts. It has lots of nice explosions and creative use of such things as a bus, a garbage truck, and a garbage disposal. It’s certainly an improvement over the original Charles Bronson/Jan Michael-Vincent version, but if you require plausibility in a movie, stay home and read a good book.

If you’re interested in learning about the life of a real hit man, check out the book Blood Relation. In it, journalist Eric Konigsberg interviews his uncle Harold “Kayo” Konigsberg who was a freelance hit man for various Mafia families and is responsible for more than 20 murders.

13 comments on “Bayard, Holmes, Movie, No Popcorn: The Mechanic

  1. But are there a lot of shirtless fight scenes? Because, I’m sorry, I’m just simple like that.

  2. Manon Eileen says:

    Great review again! Love that you’re doing this.

    I … kind of like action movies, but I prefer the more “intelligent” ones, if that makes sense. I saw the trailer for this one and it had too many explosions for me. I’ll leave watching this movie to my boyfriend and a friend of his, who tend to like movies like this a lot. Lol.

    • Piper Bayard says:

      I know what you mean about liking intelligent action movies. One of my favorites is The 13th Warrior. I don’t know if that qualifies as intelligent, but with 12 Nordic warriors and Antonio Banderas, the fewer IQ points it needs to get a pass. Thanks for stopping by.

  3. Idol says:

    […] Bayard, Holmes, Movie, No Popcorn: The Mechanic « Author Piper Bayard Posted in Tv Stars | Tags: Life Experience […]

  4. educlaytion says:

    Another “cool guys don’t flinch when they walk away from explosions” movie huh? I may check it out, but I don’t know. I like the actors, but there’s so much like this. I do love the Jan Michael Vincent reference though. I haven’t thought about that guy since breakfast.

    • Piper Bayard says:

      Lol. Until I wrote this, I hadn’t thought about Jan Michael-Vincent since I quit wearing psychodelic bell bottoms. The explosions were fun, though. Thanks for stopping by.

  5. […] This post was mentioned on Twitter by FG Middlebrook, Fallen Angel. Fallen Angel said: Looking for a great movie review? Look no further! Bayard, Holmes, Movie, No Popcorn: The Mechanic: […]

  6. Chaz says:

    I have are few airtight plots in movies. Even the movie of all movies, The Godfather, leaves one questioning how certain things could be. So do my best to just be entertained by what a movie tries to achieve.

    Wondering if this is a reversal knock-off of the 1970’s movie by the same name starring Charles Bronson and Jan Michael Vincent. In this Mechanic, the understudy discovers that his mentor had actually killed his father so maybe it is kind of reversal in that respect… who knows.

    The new Mechanic as you describe it certainly makes my list of wanna-sees. I like action movies with some depth.



    • Piper Bayard says:

      Hi Chaz. It is a knock-off of the 1972 Charles Bronson, Jan Michael-Vincent movie. Fortunately, this one manages to leave out that ridiculous suicide attempt by Jill Ireland. I won’t compare them too much, though, as to not be a spoiler for those who haven’t seen the new one. Thanks so much for stopping by. 🙂

  7. andrewmocete says:

    I am late to the Piper blog. Again. Seems I can’t remember anything these days unless it’s delivered to my email. Well, now I’m subscribed so that problem’s solved. Tangent alert. Maybe I should get to what THIS post is about before I totally hijack your home.

    This sounds like most of the Jason Statham movies I’ve seen. Very implausible. In some ways like watching a cartoon, but Statham is just so good at it. I’ll check it out. The pool scene makes me want to watch it most of all.

    You and Holmes might like The Bank Job. Good heist movie and it’s an anomaly among the Stathams because there’s (what?) character development. Great review.

    • Piper Bayard says:

      Hi Andrew. I honestly wouldn’t mind seeing more of Jason Statham, as he’s the sort of fellow I would pay to watch in a grocery shopping documentary. This one did have some cool explosions, and I didn’t mind the matinee price, hence the .38 special rating. I’ll check out The Bank Job. Thanks for the tip. Thanks, too, for subscribing and taking the time to comment. 🙂

      • andrewmocete says:

        “I honestly wouldn’t mind seeing more of Jason Statham, as he’s the sort of fellow I would pay to watch in a grocery shopping documentary.”

        Hahahahahaha! That is all.

Talk to us. We talk back.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.